71 Stoney Hill Road
Vineyard Haven, MA · $3,990,000
Zillow ↗
📊 STR projections🏖️ Beach distances🌊 Flood-zone risk📄 Investment dossier💰 Cash-flow analysis

71 Stoney Hill Road

Vineyard Haven, MA 02568
$3,990,000
278 days on market · Listed Mar 17, 2026
Data refreshed Apr 8, 2026
🌊 Not in FEMA SFHA
View on Zillow ↗
Type
SF
Beds
5
Baths
5
Sq Ft
5,598
Acres
7.1
Year Built
2007
$ / Sq Ft
$713
Days on Market
278

Investment Snapshot

🟡 MEDIUM RISK
Monthly Carrying
$21,756
Cash Flow / yr
$-245,070
Cash-on-Cash
-21.9%
Cash Required
$1,117,200
Projected Revenue / yr
$50,422
Avg Daily Rate
$234
Occupancy
59%
STR Range (P50)
$36,748
🟡 MEDIUM RISK — Registration required.
STR revenue range: $24,563$50,859

Location & Nearby

Map of 71 Stoney Hill Road, Vineyard Haven MA with nearby beaches and points of interest
HThis property
  • A
    🐕 Tisbury Dog Park (John G Rogers)
    1.00 mi
  • B
    🍽️ Scottish Bakehouse
    1.33 mi
  • C
    🌲 Tisbury Meadow Preserve
    1.47 mi
  • D
    🚴 Correllus State Forest Bike Trails
    1.58 mi
  • E
    🌲 Manuel F. Correllus State Forest
    1.60 mi
  • F
    🍽️ The Black Dog Bakery Café (State St.)
    1.60 mi
  • G
    🛒 MVY Co-op
    1.66 mi
  • H
    🍽️ Woodland Variety & Grill
    1.66 mi

About this property

A combination of luxury, comfort, and natural beauty, this expansive custom, 6,000+ square foot, five bedroom, post and beam home is sited on more than seven acres of land, surrounded by more than 200 acres of Land Bank property. From the moment you step inside, you'll be captivated by the attention to detail and the high-end finishes throughout. The open concept layout allows for seamless flow from one room to the next, perfect for entertaining or simply enjoying daily living. The great room features a beautiful custom Johnny Hoy stone fireplace, cypress ceiling, white ash flooring, and custom cabinetry. High end chef's kitchen with breakfast bar opens into the dining area. Home has state of the art technology, solar panels, and an elevator. From the screened porch, with a second custom fireplace by Johnny Hoy, to the expansive finished basement with media room, this home invites you to enjoy many amazing spaces. Main floor offers the open living concept as well as a separate den, two offices, and two bedrooms, including the primary bedroom suite with office and bathroom.

📋 Vineyard Haven Short-Term Rental Rules
Registration, taxes, occupancy caps, and enforcement for STRs in Vineyard Haven
Listed by Sheila M Morse, Island Real Estate