2 Nautilus Lane
Nantucket, MA · $4,750,000
Zillow ↗
📊 STR projections🏖️ Beach distances🌊 Flood-zone risk📄 Investment dossier💰 Cash-flow analysis

2 Nautilus Lane

Nantucket, MA 02554
$4,750,000
63 days on market · Listed Mar 1, 2026
Data refreshed Apr 8, 2026
Tax: $10,225/yr (2025)
View on Zillow ↗
Type
SF
Beds
5
Baths
5
Sq Ft
5,737
Acres
0.23
Year Built
2018
$ / Sq Ft
$828
Days on Market
63

Investment Snapshot

🟡 MEDIUM RISK
Monthly Carrying
$24,755
Cash Flow / yr
$-157,246
Cash-on-Cash
-11.8%
Cash Required
$1,330,000
Projected Revenue / yr
$217,190
Avg Daily Rate
$1,190
Occupancy
50%
STR Range (P50)
$158,102
🟡 MEDIUM RISK — Registration required. Seasonal restrictions.
STR revenue range: $100,286$219,895

Location & Nearby

Map of 2 Nautilus Lane, Nantucket MA with nearby beaches and points of interest
HThis property
  • A
    🌲 Squam Farm
    0.60 mi
  • B
    🌲 Beechwood Farm
    0.65 mi
  • C
    🚤 Polpis Harbor Boat Ramp
    0.67 mi
  • D
    🌲 Holly Farm
    0.74 mi
  • E
    🌲 Stump Pond Conservation Area
    1.03 mi
  • F
    🌲 Masquetuck Reservation
    1.72 mi
  • G
    🚴 Polpis Road Bike Path
    1.91 mi
  • H
    🌲 Coskata-Coatue Wildlife Refuge
    2.22 mi

About this property

Nestled in Surfside along bike routes is a unique blend of classic New England charm and modern luxury. This stunning property features a beautifully designed open floor plan, perfect for entertaining and family gatherings. With 5 spacious bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, there's ample room for relaxation and privacy. The heart of the home is the gourmet kitchen, equipped with high-end appliances, custom cabinetry, and a generous island that invites culinary creativity. The adjacent dining area flows seamlessly into a cozy living room, adorned with large windows that bathe the space in natural light and provide picturesque views of the surrounding landscape. Kitchen was just remodeled 2025/26. Step outside to enjoy the meticulously landscaped garden, complete with a patio area perfect for al fresco dining and summer barbecues. Enjoy the recently added pool with friends and family. The proximity to pristine beaches, quaint shops, bike routes, and fine dining enhances the allure of this home.

Similar listings in Nantucket

📋 Nantucket Short-Term Rental Rules
Registration, taxes, occupancy caps, and enforcement for STRs in Nantucket
Listed by Brody Murphy Novak Group, Douglas Elliman Real Estate - Park Plaza