4428 Main Street
Barnstable, MA · $2,199,000
Zillow ↗
📊 STR projections🏖️ Beach distances🌊 Flood-zone risk📄 Investment dossier💰 Cash-flow analysis

4428 Main Street

Barnstable, MA 02630
$2,199,000
7 days on market · Listed Sep 29, 2026
Data refreshed Oct 2, 2026
No longer active (DEL)🌊 Not in FEMA SFHA
View on Zillow ↗
Type
SF
Beds
4
Baths
3.5
Sq Ft
3,424
Acres
1.62
Year Built
1660
$ / Sq Ft
$642
Days on Market
7

Investment Snapshot

Monthly Carrying
$••,•••
Cash Flow / yr
$••,•••
Cash-on-Cash
••%
Cash Required
$••,•••
Projected Revenue / yr
$••,•••
Avg Daily Rate
$••,•••
Occupancy
••%
STR Range (P50)
$••,•••

Location & Nearby

Map of 4428 Main Street, Barnstable MA with nearby beaches and points of interest
HThis property
  • A
    ⛳ Cummaquid Golf Club
    0.21 mi
  • B
    🍽️ Leonessa
    0.30 mi
  • C
    🍦 Hallet's Store
    0.70 mi
  • D
    🍽️ Inaho Japanese Restaurant
    0.76 mi
  • E
    🍽️ Jack's Outback Restaurant
    0.77 mi
  • F
    🐟 Dennis Pond Beach
    0.91 mi
  • G
    🍽️ Old Yarmouth Inn
    1.07 mi
  • H
    🌲 Long Pasture Wildlife Sanctuary
    1.10 mi

About this property

A true storybook property where centuries of history and timeless charm come together with thoughtful updates for today's lifestyle. Welcome to the Captain John Gorham home! Originally built in 1660, this remarkable 3,424-square-foot Colonial has been thoughtfully renovated over the years. As you enter this home, the custom-kitchen with soapstone counters, SS appliances and gas range offers a warm and inviting gathering space. The eat-in kitchen overlooks the gardens and backyard, creating a wonderful connection between the home and its enchanting grounds. Wide-pine floors, custom moldings, and carefully preserved architectural details throughout the main residence beautifully blend the old with the new. An adjoining living room and family room provide inviting spaces for gathering with family and friends, while a private dining area and home office complete the main floor. The second floor offers 4 spacious bedrooms, laundry room and 2 updated bathrooms that preserve the character of the home. A private-entry apartment attached to the rear of the home provides exceptional flexibility for guests, extended family, or additional accommodations. The spacious barn provides tremendous potential for a studio, office, additional living space, or ADU. Set on 1.62 acres, the beautiful landscaped property offers a variety of choices for everyone. From playing games on the open field, growing vegetables in the established fenced-in garden, swinging on the tree-swing or relaxing in the saltwater pool and hot tub. The location of this home is ideal for shopping, beaches, and golfing. The sidewalk connects you to the Lighthouse Keeper's Pantry, other local favorite restaurants, and the scenic Mill Creek is just minutes away. Rich in history and thoughtfully updated over time, this is a truly special property with a story all its own.

Similar listings in Barnstable

📋 Barnstable Short-Term Rental Rules
Registration, taxes, occupancy caps, and enforcement for STRs in Barnstable →
Listed by Colleen Golden, Coldwell Banker Realty - Norwell - Hanover Regional Office